Can Your Insurer Refuse to Pay Because You Hired Your Own Contractor? (Virginia)

BYSteve Jafari, General ManagerNORTHERN VIRGINIA, MARYLAND & D.C.

Not because of who you hired, in our reading of Va. Code § 38.2-517(A)(1), which says no person shall require an insured to use designated repair facilities or services “as a prerequisite to settling or paying any claim.” That is not a promise that any invoice will be paid. An insurer still pays only for a covered loss and for the reasonable cost of necessary work, whoever does it, and many policies let the insurer choose to repair the property itself. If a claim is denied, Virginia rules require a reasonable written explanation. Enforcement of these rules runs through the State Corporation Commission.
Call 1-888-29-FLOODCan your insurer refuse to pay because you hired your own contractor?
Not because of who you hired, in our reading of Virginia law. Va. Code § 38.2-517 says: “No person shall: 1. Require an insured or claimant to utilize designated replacement or repair facilities or services, or the products of designated manufacturers, as a prerequisite to settling or paying any claim arising under a policy or policies of insurance;” Refusing a claim because the homeowner did not use the insurer's designated contractor would, on our reading, turn that contractor into a prerequisite to payment.
That reading has a limit we state plainly. We found no Virginia court decision or State Corporation Commission order that applies § 38.2-517 to a restoration or water mitigation company. It is our reading of the statute's words, not a ruling.
It also answers a narrower question than many people hope. It does not mean an insurer must pay your contractor's invoice. An insurer can still question coverage, cost and necessity on any claim, whoever did the work, and those questions are set out below.
Restoration Doctor is a restoration contractor, not a public adjuster or a law firm. This is general information, not legal advice, and it does not interpret your policy.
What do Virginia's claim settlement rules say?
Virginia's claims regulation adds duties that bear on any refusal. 14VAC5-400-70 says: “An insurer shall not unreasonably refuse to pay any claim in accordance with the provisions of the policy.” The same section says: “An insurer shall provide a reasonable written explanation of the basis for any claim denial. The written explanation shall provide a specific reference to a policy provision, condition, or exclusion, if any.”
Virginia's unfair claim settlement statute, Va. Code § 38.2-510, lists among its prohibited practices “Refusing arbitrarily and unreasonably to pay claims;” and “Failing to promptly provide a reasonable explanation of the basis in the insurance policy in relation to the facts or applicable law for denial of a claim”.
For protective work in particular, Virginia's homeowners policy rule, 14VAC5-342-40, says: “Insurers shall provide coverage for the cost of making reasonable repairs to protect covered property from further damage when the repairs are directly attributable to damage caused by a covered cause of loss.” The rule's text does not say who must make those repairs. Under 14VAC5-342-10, the chapter applies to policies delivered or issued for delivery in Virginia “with effective dates on and after December 31, 2023.”
Enforcement has a limit of its own. § 38.2-510(B) says: “No violation of this section shall of itself be deemed to create any cause of action in favor of any person other than the Commission;” Section 38.2-517 names the Commission as the body that investigates written complaints, and we read it as giving no private lawsuit of its own. In our reading, a homeowner's own route is the policy itself or a complaint to the Commission. Questions about legal remedies belong with an attorney.

What can an insurer still question, whoever did the work?
Hiring your own contractor removes one ground for refusal on our reading. It leaves every other policy question in place, and it is better to know them before the work starts.
- Coverage. Virginia's protective-repair rule reaches repairs “directly attributable to damage caused by a covered cause of loss.” If the cause of the water is excluded, the contractor's name does not change that.
- Reasonable cost and necessary work. The 1991 edition of the ISO Homeowners 3 form, an older edition we could read in full, says “we will pay the reasonable cost incurred by you for necessary measures taken solely to protect against further damage.” An insurer can ask whether a cost was reasonable or a measure necessary on any invoice.
- Limits. The same form says that coverage “Does not increase the limit of liability,” and Virginia's rule says “The repairs are included as part of the amount of the loss.”
- Neglect. Virginia's homeowners rule, 14VAC5-342-60, allows policies to exclude “Neglect of the insured to use all reasonable means to protect the property during and after a loss.”
- The insurer's option to repair. 14VAC5-342-70 lets an insurer “repair, rebuild, or replace the damaged property with other of like kind and quality within a reasonable time,” with notice “Within 30 days after receiving the insured's proof of loss”. When an insurer makes that election, it chooses who does the repair. How that fits with § 38.2-517 is not settled, and we found no Virginia authority on it.
- Endorsements. In Florida, some policyholders accept a preferred contractor endorsement when they buy the policy. We found none in a Virginia homeowners form, but we have not read every form, so check your declarations page and endorsements.

What does the data show about insurer repair programs?
Hiring your own contractor is a common choice, and so is using the insurer's program. J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study, as reported by Claims Journal on March 18, 2026, surveyed 5,093 customers between December 2024 and December 2025. It described direct repair program results “among the 41% of customers using these programs.”
The same report found that for higher-severity claims, “Repair cycles for these customers were more than two weeks shorter on average.” Across the study, “The average time required to complete a repair was 29.6 days,” and “the average time before customers received final payment was 40.7 days, down 3.4 days.” Overall satisfaction “rose 20 points to 702 on a 1,000-point scale.”
Those are national figures, not Virginia-only. They show that a program can move faster on large losses, which is worth weighing honestly against your reasons for hiring someone directly.
What steps help, without turning into claim advice?
Questions about reasonable cost and necessary work are answered with records. These steps are general and apply to any contractor, program or not.
- Photograph the damage before any work starts, and keep receipts for what you spend.
- Get a written agreement and an itemized invoice from whoever you hire.
- Keep the job records: dated photographs, daily moisture readings, an equipment log and a drying record.
- Read your policy, including the declarations page and endorsements, for option-to-repair or preferred contractor wording.
- If a claim or a line item is refused, ask the insurer for its explanation in writing, with the policy provision it relies on.
- If you cannot resolve it with the insurer, the Bureau of Insurance publishes how to file an insurance complaint.

What is Restoration Doctor's view?
This section is our view as a restoration contractor, not a statement of law.
We think the name on the truck should not decide whether a covered loss is paid. We also think the honest test of any invoice, ours included, is whether its records show the work was reasonable and necessary. That is why we document every job the same way, whoever ends up paying.
We are hired by the property owner under a written agreement, and we invoice the property owner, whatever the insurer pays. We give you a complete claim file: photographs, moisture readings, equipment logs and an itemized invoice. Virginia reserves acting for a policyholder in negotiating a claim settlement to licensed public adjusters under Va. Code § 38.2-1845.12. We are not one, and we do not represent you in your claim.
Where are these rules written down?
Every rule and figure quoted above is linked to its own text below. Read the source rather than a summary of it, including this one. Each page was read on November 21, 2026.
- Sources:
- Va. Code § 38.2-517, unfair settlement practices; replacement and repair; penalty — subdivision (A)(1) and subsection (C)
- Va. Code § 38.2-510, unfair claim settlement practices — subdivisions (A)(4) and (A)(14), subsection (B)
- 14VAC5-400-70, claims settlement standards applicable to all insurers — subsections (B) and (E)
- 14VAC5-342-10, scope and applicability
- 14VAC5-342-40, mandatory property coverages — subsection (L)
- 14VAC5-342, full chapter — 14VAC5-342-60 permitted exclusions
- 14VAC5-342-70, loss settlement condition — subsection (I)
- ISO Homeowners 3 form, HO 00 03 04 91 — a 1991 edition, posted by the Nevada Division of Insurance; later editions exist and wording varies by insurer
- Va. Code § 38.2-1845.12, standards of conduct for public adjusters
- Virginia State Corporation Commission, Bureau of Insurance: File a Complaint
- Claims Journal, March 18, 2026: report on the J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study


